I made a rookie email marketer mistake

Earlier this year, I helped a client promote their first 2025 production. It was a rare winter product—something I had never heard of before working with this client.

So, I came up with a great positioning.

I teased the product for 2 to 3 days.

I sold 90% of their 2025 inventory in the first email.

I sold out all stocks with only 2 emails in 3 days.

I was proud. 

THEN

I made a rookie mistake.

A month later

The client restocked one of their most expensive products—$800 a kilo. (3-time the previous one)

But this time…

My expectations were high—too high.

Because I couldn’t help but wonder…

“What if I sell out their most expensive product with one email again?”

So… I sent out my campaign and started refreshing the page.

…

…

It was a total disaster.

…

…

Okay. I’m exaggerating a bit.

I sold ~25% of their inventory with the first email. 

I made more sales with one email than the total inventory they could move in 3 weeks last year.

(I’m still tracking the data when I write this email… so I don’t know how many days will it take to clear their inventory)

But the lesson:

Do not get too attached to the result of any single campaign.

Do not expect a home run with every swing. 

Do not sit in front of your computer, refreshing the dashboard.

But the good news is – 

If you’re unhappy with one campaign, you can always send a second… or third. You will make more sales with every single email.

That’s the beauty of email marketing.

Talk soon,
– WYH